A new report reveals that soaring reconstruction costs and shrinking insurance coverage are creating financial devastation for wildfire victims across the American West, with many homeowners discovering their policies fall hundreds of thousands of dollars short of actual rebuilding expenses.
The Cotality Wildfire Risk Report 2025 highlights the growing insurance crisis through cases like Los Angeles homeowners Michael and Elena Torres. After the 2025 wildfires destroyed their home, the longtime policyholders discovered their $750,000 dwelling limit fell $250,000 short of the $1 million reconstruction cost.
“Average dwelling limits can lag true reconstruction costs by six figures or more,” the report noted, describing what researchers call “the underinsurance shock.”
The analysis identifies nearly 2.6 million homes at moderate or greater wildfire risk across the western United States, representing $1.3 trillion in reconstruction value. California accounts for 1.26 million of these at-risk properties, worth approximately $796.1 billion.
Los Angeles leads metropolitan areas with 240,973 homes facing moderate or greater wildfire risk, representing $191.8 billion in reconstruction value. Other high-risk metros include Riverside, California; San Diego; Sacramento; and Austin, Texas.
Major insurers continue withdrawing from wildfire-exposed regions. California’s Fair Access to Insurance Requirements Plan now covers more than 452,000 policies, more than double the 2020 total. Colorado has seen average premiums surge nearly 60% over five years, while Oregon homeowners face quadrupled premiums as carriers pull back from central, southern and eastern counties.
The insurance shortage directly impacts mortgage lending. When premiums exceed 3% of buyer income, first-time buyers struggle to meet debt-to-income requirements, the report said.
Nine months after the January 2025 Los Angeles fires, which damaged over 13,500 properties and caused more than $40 billion in insured losses, rebuilding efforts remain stalled. Los Angeles County issued fewer than 50 rebuilding permits by late May, with only 15 permits issued in fire-damaged Altadena.
Contractor shortages, construction loan interest rates between 10% and 12%, and inflated material costs compound the challenges facing homeowners attempting to rebuild.
The financial strain appears in mortgage data. Los Angeles County saw 30-to-119-day delinquencies climb from 1.87% in December 2024 to 2.22% in February 2025. Meanwhile, Ventura and Orange Counties, which avoided the worst January fires, saw delinquency rates decrease over the same period.
The report introduces analysis of “wildfire-induced conflagration,” where fires transition from burning vegetation to structures. This phenomenon affected major recent disasters including the 2025 Los Angeles fires, the 2023 Lahaina fire, and the 2021 Marshall fire.
In the Eaton Fire, 75% of properties within the fire perimeter were rated low-to-moderate wildfire hazard while having high conflagration hazard. For the Palisades Fire, 37% of properties fell into this category.
The analysis suggests traditional wildfire risk assessments may inadequately capture the full threat landscape facing Western communities.
What are your thoughts on the latest data? Share your insights in the comments below.
