Savvy and experienced insurance brokers pay close attention to the annual J.D. Power rankings. J.D. Power's home insurance rankings and auto insurance ratings provide brokers with valuable benchmarks for assessing carriers and advising clients.
In this article, we’ll delve into important information about this consumer insights company and discuss how important its rankings are to the insurance industry.
Headquartered in Troy, Michigan, J.D. Power and Associates was founded in 1968 by James David Power III. It is a consumer intelligence and analytics company known for its independent research, data analysis, and ratings.
Its rankings influence a wide range of industries, including travel, automotive, banking, and insurance, which this article focuses on. J.D. Power is recognized for its customer satisfaction surveys and performance benchmarks. These are widely used by both consumers and businesses to make informed purchase decisions.
The firm conducts annual insurance ratings, including the J.D. Power home insurance rankings and J.D. Power auto insurance ratings. These ranking surveys evaluate customer satisfaction, claims handling, pricing, and other key factors.
J.D. Power insurance ratings are based on feedback from thousands of policyholders and are considered a trusted resource for both consumers and industry professionals. The company’s findings are often used as references by risk managers, brokers, insurers, and consumers. The rankings help them to compare providers, assess service quality, and inform purchasing decisions.
When it comes to assessing the viability of an insurer, brokers typically base their decisions by using both J.D. Power rankings and equally important information provided by insurance ratings agencies.
J.D. Power’s insurance ratings are developed through comprehensive, independent consumer surveys and rigorous data analysis, providing valuable benchmarks for both insurance companies and consumers. These ratings are especially influential in the auto insurance and homeowners’ insurance sectors, where overall customer satisfaction and customer service are critical.
Here's an overview of the process:
J.D. Power conducts extensive surveys each year, gathering feedback from tens of thousands of policyholders across the US. For example, the 2024 US Auto Insurance Study included responses from over 41,000 car insurance customers. The Home Insurance Study, meanwhile, surveyed homeowners’ insurance policyholders nationwide and by region.
Studies cover auto insurance, home insurance, and other products, with specific attention to regional leaders like State Farm and Auto Club of Southern California.
J.D. Power survey respondents rate their insurance company on several factors. These include:
These criteria are central to both the auto insurance study and home insurance study.
The insurance study also evaluates satisfaction with claims handling, focusing on the fairness of settlements, communication, and the speed and ease of resolving claims.
Each insurance company is scored on a 1,000-point scale, with higher scores reflecting superior overall customer satisfaction. Rankings are provided nationally and by region to account for differences in market presence and service quality.
Top-performing insurers in each region may receive J.D. Power awards, which are recognized in the industry and often referenced in marketing.
J.D. Power periodically updates its insurance rating methodologies to reflect evolving consumer expectations and industry trends. This ensures that the auto insurance study and home insurance study remain relevant and accurate.
J.D. Power maintains strict independence in its insurance studies. Insurance companies cannot influence the results, though those that excel may license the use of J.D. Power awards for promotional purposes.
The company openly publishes its methodologies and results, allowing consumers and industry professionals to trust the validity of its rankings.
J.D. Power uses the parameters when coming up with its insurance ratings:
Overall customer satisfaction: this is an aggregate measure reflecting the customer’s total experience with the insurance company
Customer service: includes quality and responsiveness of interactions with agents and representatives
Ease of doing business: measures the simplicity and convenience for customers to manage policies, file claims, and access services
Problem resolution: measures effectiveness and fairness in handling complaints, claims, and disputes
Pricing: this is the perceived fairness and competitiveness of premiums and rates
Products and coverage options: refer to the variety and suitability of insurance products offered
Digital channels: rates the quality and usability of online tools, mobile apps, and digital communication
Trust: the level of customer confidence in the insurer’s reliability and integrity
Claims process: measures the speed, transparency, and fairness in settling claims
These factors are measured through large-scale consumer surveys and are weighted to produce a score out of 1,000 for each insurance company. The results are reported nationally and by region.
This is an award that signifies excellence in customer satisfaction and service. J.D. Power has been giving out these awards since the 1980s. These awards are based on the customer satisfaction surveys and research it conducted and are sometimes highlighted by the awardees as part of their marketing.
There are several benefits to scoring high in a J.D. Power survey, and it’s an objective that insurance companies may find worth working towards.
Reputation and credibility: A high J.D. Power insurance rating signals strong overall customer satisfaction, customer service, and problem resolution. This enhances the insurer’s reputation in a competitive market
Marketing advantage: Companies can leverage J.D. Power awards in advertising and promotional materials, attracting and retaining customers
Operational insights: The feedback and data from J.D. Power studies help insurers identify strengths and areas for improvement, supporting better business decisions and service enhancements
Trusted reference: High J.D. Power insurance ratings can serve as an objective benchmark when recommending insurers to build trust with clients
Sales tool: Highlighting a company’s strong performance in areas like ease of doing business, digital channels, and claims handling helps brokers differentiate offerings and close sales more effectively
Client confidence: Brokers can assure clients they are being matched with insurers recognized for excellent service and customer satisfaction
Enhanced client services and support: Poring through J.D. Power insurance ratings simplifies the task of finding and recommending viable providers to clients. Clients cannot go through every insurer they come across, and it’s difficult enough for them to get familiar with the many insurance terms
Informed choices: J.D. Power ratings can help consumers compare insurers in terms of factors that matter most, such as pricing, claims experience, and customer service
Peace of mind: Choosing a highly rated insurer increases the likelihood of a positive experience, especially when filing insurance claims or seeking support
Transparency: J.D. Power’s independent, data-driven approach provides consumers with reliable information to guide their insurance decisions
Whenever brokers are tasked to find suitable insurance providers and products, they can use J.D. Power insurance ratings in ways that can benefit their clients. These include:
By referencing J.D. Power’s independent ratings, brokers can guide clients toward insurance companies with proven records of overall customer satisfaction, strong customer service, and effective problem resolution
Highlighting high J.D. Power scores builds client confidence, as these ratings are widely recognized in the industry.
Brokers can match clients with insurers that excel in specific areas important to them. These include digital channels for tech-savvy clients or claims satisfaction for those prioritizing support during loss.
Using J.D. Power data, brokers can provide clear, reliable comparisons, helping clients make informed decisions based on real customer experiences.
By recommending highly rated insurers, brokers help clients secure policies with companies more likely to deliver reliable service and fair claims handling. This leads to greater satisfaction and fewer future issues.
How do the ratings from J.D. Power compare to the ratings of insurance ratings agencies A.M. Best, Fitch, Moody’s and S&P? J.D. Power insurance ratings and traditional insurance ratings agencies serve different but complementary roles in the insurance industry.
J.D. Power insurance ratings focus on customer experience. These ratings are based on large-scale consumer surveys that measure key customer satisfaction metrics. The results of these surveys show how policyholders feel about their insurance company’s service and support.
For brokers and clients, J.D. Power ratings provide insight into which insurers deliver the best experience from the customer’s perspective.
Meanwhile, insurance ratings agencies evaluate the financial strength ratings (FSR) and stability of insurance companies. Their ratings are based on a company’s ability to meet its financial obligations, pay claims, and remain solvent during economic stress or after major disasters. Their ratings help brokers and clients assess the long-term reliability and security of an insurer.
| Aspect | J.D. Power insurance ratings | Insurance rating agencies |
|---|---|---|
| Primary focus | Customer satisfaction and service quality | Financial strength and claims-paying ability |
| Basis of ratings | Large-scale consumer surveys | Financial analysis, balance sheets, and risk assessment |
| Key criteria | Claims handling, pricing, problem resolution, digital channels, overall customer satisfaction | Capital adequacy, liquidity, investment risk, underwriting performance |
| Audience | Policyholders, brokers, industry professionals | Brokers, risk managers, investors, regulators |
| Purpose | Compare insurers based on customer experience | Assess insurer’s ability to meet financial obligations |
| Frequency | Annually (by product and region) | Ongoing, with periodic reviews and updates |
| Output | 1,000-point scale, regional and national rankings | Letter grades (e.g., A++, AA, Baa) |
| Sample use | Selecting insurers with high customer satisfaction | Ensuring insurer’s long-term financial security |
In summary, J.D. Power ratings highlight customer satisfaction and service quality, while insurance ratings agencies focus on financial health and claims-paying ability. Brokers and clients can benefit most by looking at both ratings. J.D. Power showcases an insurer’s service quality and experience, while ratings agencies expose their financial stability and security.
With these insurance ratings, brokers, risk managers, or even those working as consultants have a reliable way to compare insurers and recommend options that meet their clients’ needs. By using these independent ratings, insurance professionals can build trust, offer clear guidance, and help their clients choose insurance companies known for strong customer satisfaction and service.
Staying informed with trusted sources like J.D. Power supports better decisions for both brokers and their clients.
Subscribe to Insurance Business Premium for exclusive access to IB+ Data Hub and other premium content.
