Choosing the right insurance provider is a critical decision for anyone seeking reliable coverage and long-term value in Massachusetts. The state's insurance market features a wide array of carriers, each with distinct advantages in terms of product variety, service quality, and financial strength.
This article provides an overview of insurance companies in Massachusetts and can help you compare options based on your needs. Understanding the key players can help you match clients with suitable insurers. This guide provides data on the largest insurance companies in the state, serving as a reference for those making informed choices in a competitive environment.
These are the top insurance companies in Massachusetts. We've listed these insurance companies according to market share data from our IB+ Data Hub.
You can find data on insurance companies in Massachusetts and other states across different lines of business by accessing our IB+ Data Hub, with data sortable by year, state, line of business, and more!
Market share: 7.55%
Travelers Group is one of the largest and most established insurance companies in the US, with a significant presence in the Bay State. This carrier offers a broad range of coverage options for both personal and commercial clients. Its portfolio includes auto, home, renters, and business insurance.
Travelers is recognized for its financial stability and offers protection against property damage and liability. It is also a major home insurer and among the top car insurance companies in the US.
Travelers offers a range of policy options and add-ons for auto insurance in Massachusetts, including collision coverage, gap insurance, and new car replacement. The company also provides uninsured motorist coverage. It offers car coverage that meets state requirements, including the state minimums for bodily injury liability ($20,000 per person/$40,000 per accident) and property damage ($5,000 per accident).
Travelers has an agent network and digital tools that make it easy to obtain quotes or manage policies online. Learn more about Travelers in this insurance ratings and review guide.
These some of the insurer's specialized offerings:
This pays for the use of environmentally friendly and energy-efficient materials when repairing or rebuilding the home after a covered loss. Travelers also offers a discount for homes certified as "green" by the LEED program. This feature may appeal to eco-conscious policyholders.
This provides up to $25,000 to help recover the policyholder's identity if it's stolen and used fraudulently. This coverage includes reimbursement for expenses like lost wages, legal fees, and document replacement.
This expands protection for personal belongings beyond standard named perils, covering a broader range of risks.
This allows policyholders to insure high-value items, such as jewelry, fine art, and musical instruments, separately, often with broader coverage and higher limits than standard policies.
This offers protection for damage caused by water backing up from sewers or drains, or from sump pump overflow. This is an add-on not always available with basic homeowners' policies.
This helps protect against unexpected construction cost increases by providing additional funds if rebuilding costs exceed the dwelling coverage limit.
Beyond the federal flood program, Travelers offers private flood insurance, including options for temporary living expenses and pool repairs.
Market share: 6.03%
Headquartered in Boston, Liberty Mutual is not only a major player among auto insurers in the Bay State but is also one of the largest insurance companies in the country. Liberty Mutual offers a broad suite of personal and commercial insurance products. The company offers customizable policies, a wide agent network, and digital tools that make it easy to manage claims and policies.
Liberty Mutual provides a variety of coverages in Massachusetts, including standard liability, property damage, uninsured motorist coverage, and several add-ons. Policyholders can choose to have higher limits, such as $50,000 per accident for bodily injury or property damage, to better protect themselves and their assets.
Here are some unique policies and add-ons from Liberty Mutual:
This auto insurance add-on provides teachers with several benefits. These include no deductibles for collisions that occur while driving on school business and coverage for vehicle damage from vandalism on school property.
This add-on provides coverage for lost or stolen jewelry without requiring an up-front appraisal or deductible. This makes claiming easier than typical scheduled personal property endorsements.
Liberty Mutual offers insurance programs for niche industries, such as auto salvage, scrap metal dealers, fire suppression contractors, and fine arts and museums. These specialty programs are managed by dedicated administrators.
A global cyber insurance product offering first- and third-party cyber coverage, including for personal losses of select executives and risks related to quantum computing and generative AI. The product also provides incident response, access to Liberty Mutual's cyber risk engineering team, and a network of vendors for security and data recovery.
This is a blended cyber and technology errors and omissions (E&O) insurance solution tailored specifically for technology companies. It combines cyber risk protection with E&O coverage, addressing the unique exposures faced by tech firms.
Market share: 5.98%
Chubb offers home and auto insurance, including coverage for luxury vehicles and classic cars. While Chubb is not usually among the cheapest car insurance options, it is used by clients seeking higher coverage limits and specialized services.
Chubb offers insurance policies that include worldwide rental car coverage and the ability to choose your own repair shop. Chubb may be suitable for those who own high-value cars or want more than basic coverage.
These are some of Chubb's specialized coverage options:
If a policyholder's car is totaled or stolen, Chubb pays the full agreed value stated in your policy, not the depreciated value. This is especially valuable for luxury and classic cars.
Chubb's auto insurance includes up to $15,000 in rental car reimbursement with no per-day limit, applicable worldwide.
Chubb guarantees that repairs will use only OEM parts, not aftermarket substitutes, for covered vehicles.
Chubb offers complimentary HomeScan inspections for homeowners insurance clients. This service uses infrared technology to detect hidden problems like leaks, insulation gaps, or faulty wiring before they cause damage.
Included as standard, this covers the full cost to rebuild a policyholder's home after a covered loss, even if it exceeds their policy limit.
If a policyholder's home is destroyed, they can opt for a cash settlement instead of rebuilding.
Chubb offers high-limit, worldwide coverage for jewelry, art, and collectibles, often without requiring itemized appraisals for lower-value items.
Chubb provides personal cyber protection, covering expenses related to cyber extortion, cyberbullying, and identity theft.
Market share: 5.88%
Progressive is among the top insurance companies in Massachusetts for drivers seeking flexible car coverage options, discounts, and online rate comparison. The insurer offers standard and optional coverage for car insurance, including liability, collision, comprehensive, uninsured and underinsured motorist, and roadside assistance.
Progressive offers customizable policies and telematics insurance, which can lower car insurance rates based on policyholders' safe driving habits. The company also provides coverage for rideshare drivers, pet injury protection, and gap insurance. For homeowners and renters, Progressive offers bundled discounts and comprehensive protection options.
Progressive recently expanded its digital services and claims technology in Massachusetts, making it easier for customers to file claims and manage policies online. The company has maintained financial stability and market share growth. You can check out our insurance rating and review of Progressive to learn more.
Progressive offers the following insurance products and features:
Progressive's telematics program tracks driving habits through a mobile app or plug-in device. Safe drivers can earn discounts based on real driving data, not just traditional risk factors.
This online tool allows customers to enter their budget and find coverage options that fit that price point.
Included with collision coverage at no extra cost, this covers veterinary bills if a policyholder's pet is injured in a car accident.
Progressive offers a specific add-on for rideshare drivers (Uber, Lyft, etc.) that fills the coverage gap between personal and commercial auto insurance.
For motorcycles, RVs, and boats, Progressive provides higher limits for custom parts, accessories, and equipment than most standard policies.
Progressive offers package policies for small businesses, including specialized coverage for contractors, food trucks, and home-based businesses.
If a plan holder's motorcycle or RV breaks down far from home, Progressive covers lodging, transportation, and food expenses.
Market share: 5.51%
Berkshire Hathaway Group is a multinational conglomerate headquartered in Omaha, Nebraska, known for its diversified holdings and leadership under Warren Buffett. Through its subsidiaries, including GEICO, Berkshire Hathaway GUARD, and Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance (BHSI), the group is a major car insurance company. BH also offers a wide range of other insurance types in Massachusetts.
GEICO, its most recognized brand for personal lines, is a popular choice for auto, motorcycle, and homeowners' coverage. Berkshire Hathaway GUARD and Specialty Insurance focuses on commercial and specialty policies for businesses of all sizes.
These are some of unique insurance products and add-ons from Berkshire Hathaway:
Unlike standard extended warranties, GEICO's MBI covers repairs to all mechanical parts of a new car. This applies after the manufacturer's warranty expires, up to seven years or 100,000 miles, whichever comes first. GEICO offers this apart from being one of the cheapest car insurance companies in Massachusetts.
This specialty insurance includes advanced cyber liability insurance with built-in incident response services. It also provides 24/7 access to cybersecurity experts, legal counsel, and public relations support in the event of a data breach.
This auto insurance policy is designed for drivers aged 50 and older, guaranteeing renewal and offering accident forgiveness, even for those who no longer drive regularly. It is tailored to a demographic often underserved by traditional auto policies.
Berkshire Hathaway provides specialized professional liability coverage for industries like technology, life sciences, and renewable energy. This offers custom endorsements for intellectual property, media, and regulatory risks.
This program allows businesses to pay workers' compensation premiums based on real-time payroll data to improve cash flow and reduce audit surprises.
For businesses with international operations, BHSI offers coordinated global insurance solutions, including centralized claims handling and compliance support. This is useful for companies navigating complex regulatory environments.
Market share: 5.11%
Plymouth Rock Insurance is a regional insurer headquartered in Boston, Massachusetts. It serves customers throughout New England, New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania. Those wanting to know its financial strength ratings (FSR) will have to look it up in regional insurance ratings agencies.
The company is known for its strong presence in Massachusetts, where it offers a variety of personal and commercial insurance products. While Plymouth Rock is recognized for its auto insurance, it also provides a variety of other types of insurance policies. The company boasts local expertise, responsive claims service, and a network of independent agents across Massachusetts.
Here are some of this regional insurer's unique offerings:
Plymouth Rock reimburses the cost of a one-time taxi or rideshare fare (up to a set limit) if a plan holder feels it is unsafe to drive home.
If a plan holder's car is damaged, Plymouth Rock will pick up the vehicle, deliver a rental car, coordinate repairs at a trusted shop, and return the car once repairs are complete. This full-service claims handling is rare.
Plymouth Rock's Crashbusters vans will go to the policyholder's location to inspect vehicle damage and help settle claims on the spot, speeding up the process compared to traditional claims handling.
This is a written commitment to high service standards, including callbacks within one business day and detailed explanations of claims decisions. If Plymouth Rock fails to meet these standards, the policyholder may be eligible for a credit on their premium.
Market share: 4.6%
Arbella Insurance Group is a regional insurance provider headquartered in Quincy, Massachusetts. It serves customers in the state, along with those in neighboring New England states. Founded in 1988, Arbella is known for its strong local presence. It focuses on personal and commercial insurance solutions to meet the needs of New England customers.
Within Massachusetts, Arbella offers a broad range of insurance products, including auto, home, condo, renters, umbrella, and business insurance. The company has a network of independent agents, responsive claims service, and community involvement. Arbella also provides specialized coverage for small businesses, commercial vehicles, and various industry sectors.
These products and coverage add-ons are unique to Arbella:
This add-on provides policyholders with a bundled discount and streamlined claims process when they combine auto and renters' insurance.
Arbella offers gap insurance to cover the difference between the insured car's actual cash value and the remaining balance on the policyholder's loan or lease if the vehicle is totaled or stolen.
Arbella's homeowners' policies can include reimbursement for expenses related to identity theft, such as legal fees and lost wages.
Market share: 2.8%
The USAA was founded in 1922 to serve active and retired military members and their families. This carrier is a member-owned financial organization headquartered in San Antonio, Texas. USAA is known for its customer service, competitive rates, and comprehensive insurance offerings.
In Massachusetts, USAA provides a variety of insurance products, as well as banking and investment services. USAA consistently ranks among the top insurance providers for customer satisfaction and claims handling. Membership eligibility is limited to military personnel, veterans, and their eligible family members.
USAA offers products that cater to active and retired servicemembers and their families, including:
This provides discounts for members who store their vehicles on a military base.
If a member is deployed and stores their vehicle, USAA provides special coverage and premium reductions for vehicles not in use.
USAA can provide auto insurance coverage for members stationed or living overseas, including shipment coverage for vehicles being transported internationally.
USAA's homeowners' insurance includes replacement cost coverage for personal belongings as a standard feature, not just actual cash value.
USAA offers optional earthquake and flood insurance endorsements for homeowners and renters, which can be bundled with standard policies for broader protection.
USAA provides optional coverage for cyberattacks, cyberbullying, and identity theft, including expense reimbursement and support services.
Market share: 2.96%
With headquarters in California, Farmers Insurance is a national carrier, offering a wide range of personal and commercial insurance products across the country. As one of the largest insurance companies in Massachusetts, Farmers provides coverage through its network of local agents and digital platforms. It serves individuals, families, and small businesses.
Although Farmers is best known for its auto, homeowners, and renters' insurance, it also offers other essential policies like life, pet, and business insurance in the state. The company offers customizable policies, a variety of discounts, and features such as its telematics program for safe driving. Check out our insurance ratings review of Farmers to learn more about this insurer.
Farmers offers unique insurance policies and add-ons, including:
Farmers offers higher limits and broader coverage for aftermarket parts, custom paint, and special equipment on cars and motorcycles.
If a policyholder's home is damaged and they choose to rebuild with green materials or energy-efficient upgrades, Farmers will help cover the additional costs.
Farmers' Identity Shield provides identity theft monitoring, resolution services, and expense reimbursement as an add-on to homeowners' or renters' insurance.
Farmers' Signal app tracks driving behavior and rewards safe drivers with discounts and gift cards. Unlike many telematics programs, Signal provides distracted driving feedback and can reward all household drivers, not just the policyholder.
Farmers offers highly customizable BOPs for small businesses, including unique endorsements for cyber liability, equipment breakdown, and employment practices liability.
Market share: 2.12%
Commonly known as AmFam, American Family Insurance Group is a national mutual insurance company headquartered in Madison, Wisconsin. The company offers a broad range of personal and commercial insurance products, including auto, homeowners, renters, life, business, and specialty insurance. American Family is known for its focus on customer service, personalized coverage options, and having a strong network of local agents.
In Massachusetts, American Family Insurance operates primarily through its subsidiary, Homesite Insurance, which specializes in homeowners, renters, and condo insurance. While AmFam is a major provider of auto and business insurance in many states, its direct presence in the Massachusetts auto insurance market is limited, with most personal lines focused on property coverage.
Learn more about American Family in this insurance ratings review.
American Family offers these products and add-ons in Massachusetts:
American Family offers an endorsement that covers water damage caused by hidden leaks or seepage.
If an insured home's siding is damaged and the original materials are no longer available, this coverage pays to replace undamaged siding to ensure a uniform appearance.
This add-on covers the repair or replacement of major home systems and appliances if they break down due to mechanical or electrical failure.
American Family offers protection for underground service lines (water, sewer, and power) that connect a home to public utilities.
Policyholders can receive a discount for installing qualifying smart home devices, such as water leak detectors or security systems.
Given all these options, how do you make the right choice among the top insurance companies?
Start by matching each insurer's strengths to what your client needs, such as basic auto coverage, protection for a high-value home, or a policy for a small business.
Always check independent ratings for financial strength and claims satisfaction, since reliability is important. You can look at our special report on insurers that ranked the highest in claims satisfaction.
It's also important to compare premiums and look for discounts that fit your client’s budget but also consider any unique features or add-ons that might suit their situation.
Make sure your client is eligible for the company, such as USAA being only for military families, and think about whether they prefer working with a local agent or managing everything online. Finally, confirm that any recommendation meets all Massachusetts insurance requirements.
When you have enough information, present the best options and discuss the pros and cons so your client can make an informed decision.
Subscribe to Insurance Business Premium for exclusive access to IB+ Data Hub and other premium content.
